top of page

Cracked New Concrete Driveway in NZ? When It Counts as a Defect and How to Dispute It

sp8002
Oct 25
4 min read

Updated: 5 days ago

A crack in a new concrete driveway is not automatically a defect. MBIE's workmanship guide treats cracks up to 3 mm wide as acceptable and unrepaired gaps over 3 mm as a defect. If yours is wider, tell the contractor in writing, ideally within 12 months of completion. Unresolved claims up to $60,000 can go to the Disputes Tribunal.

The 3 mm line

The main reference is MBIE's Guide to Tolerances, Materials and Workmanship in New Residential Construction (2015), written to help homeowners and contractors decide what counts as a defect. Section 1.4 covers concreted driveways and paths. It lists cracks up to 3 mm wide as acceptable and unrepaired gaps wider than 3 mm as a defect. It also says plainly that cracking in concrete is common and is not necessarily a sign of poor workmanship.

So the first job is to measure. A feeler gauge or a plastic crack-width card from a hardware store will do it. Measure at the widest point, photograph the gauge in the crack with a ruler beside it, and note the date. Do it again a month later. A crack that keeps widening, or one where one side has dropped below the other, is a stronger case than a hairline that has stopped moving.

Why new concrete cracks

Concrete shrinks as it dries. If nothing controls where it cracks, it picks its own line. The usual causes are:

  • Saw-cut or tooled joints missing, too far apart or cut too late, so shrinkage cracks run across the slab instead of along the joints.

  • A thin slab, or a soft or poorly compacted base underneath, so the slab bends under a car.

  • Heavy vehicles on the slab before it reached strength, such as a concrete truck or a loaded trailer.

  • Tree roots, poor drainage or ground movement after the job was finished.

The first three point at the contractor. The last one usually does not. The MBIE guide also says a contractor is not liable for damage done by people outside their control, for example a delivery truck you booked separately.

Your rights: two laws can apply

If the driveway was built under a residential building contract, for example as part of a new house, the Building Act 2004 adds implied warranties to the contract. The work must be done in a proper and competent manner, with suitable materials and with reasonable skill and care. There is also a 12-month defect repair period. If you notify the contractor in writing within 12 months of completion, the onus is on them to fix the defect or prove it is not one. After that, the warranties still run for the rest of the 10-year limitation period, but the onus shifts to you.

For any driveway job done for your home, the Consumer Guarantees Act also applies. The work must be done with reasonable care and skill and be fit for the purpose you described. If the contractor refuses to fix a problem, or takes longer than a reasonable time, you can get someone else to do it and claim the cost back. If the failure is serious, you can cancel and seek compensation.

This is general information, not legal advice. Citizens Advice Bureau and Community Law Centres give free advice on which path fits your contract.

How to dispute it, step by step

  • Measure and photograph the cracks, with the date, a ruler and the crack-width reading in shot.

  • Find the contract, quote, specification and invoice. Note the slab thickness, mesh and joint spacing if they were written down.

  • Write to the contractor. Describe each crack, attach the photos, ask them to inspect and repair within a set time, and keep a copy.

  • If they dispute it, get an independent report from a concrete specialist or engineer. Ask for the likely cause, not just a repair price.

  • If it is still unresolved, file with the Disputes Tribunal. It hears claims up to $60,000, and you present the case yourself. Above that, talk to a lawyer.

What the repair costs if you end up paying

Crack sealing on concrete runs from a few hundred dollars. Re-pouring broken sections costs $300 to $500 per m². Our concrete driveway repair cost guide breaks those figures down. If the slabs are stable and you would rather cover the cracks than chase them, an asphalt overlay costs $100 to $160 per m². Our guide to asphalt over a concrete driveway explains when that works and when it does not.

If your driveway is asphalt, not concrete

The same MBIE guide has a separate standard for asphalt driveways in section 1.3: isolated cracks more than 2 mm wide count as a defect, as do depressions deeper than 3 mm. If you paid for asphalt work that has failed, our note on what to do when a paid patch fails covers the Consumer Guarantees Act steps for that case.

Where Rapidpatch fits

We repair concrete and asphalt, including cracked slabs and vehicle crossings. Our concrete crack repair guide explains which cracks matter. Once a dispute is settled, we can repair the slab sections, or overlay where that makes sense. See our driveway repair service, or send a photo and we will tell you which repair suits your slab.

For how a new driveway should be built (thickness, base, mesh, joints and curing), see new concrete driveway cost and spec.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page